November/December Students and Teachers of the Month
Always put the children and those who teach them first; they are our future.
TOTAL NUMBER OF STUDENTS AWARDED: 38
TOTAL NUMBER OF TEACHERS AWARDED: 22
Each month’s Student and Teacher of the Month T-shirts are characterized by a unique color. The color for November’s Student and Teacher of the Month T-shirts is green, while December’s color is red.
In the spirit of the holidays, we have decided to make December a “Super Month” for the Student of the Month program and award three students from each school instead of the usual one student.
We awarded three Students of the Month at Eliot Middle School. 7th graders Ariana Artieda, Jose Castillo, and Erick Marroquin were selected as Eliot’s Students of the Month.
Ariana, Jose, and Erick received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Ariana Artieda, Jose Castillo, and Erick Marroquin
On December 18th, 2009, we awarded three Students of the Month at Burbank Elementary. Principal Kelly Lawson selected Cindy Huizar, Juan Rivas, and Kial Schweiter as Burbank’s Students of the Month.
Cindy, Juan, and Kial received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Burbank’s Teacher of the Month was Linda Chang, who received a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $10 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt. We also honored Principal Kelly Lawson with a Teacher of the Month sweater.
Herbert Simmons, Kial Schweiter, Juan Rivas, Linda Chang, Cindy Huizar, and Principal Kelly Lawson
Later that day, we awarded three Students of the Month at Franklin Elementary. Principal Caroline Bermudez selected Jose Chigo Mendez, Kelli Johnson, and David Avina as Franklin’s Students of the Month. Each student received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Principal Bermudez selected Mrs. Luna, also known as “Madame Presidente”, as Franklin’s Teacher of the Month. Mrs. Luna received a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
David Avina and parents, Mrs. Luna, Principal Caroline Bermudez, Jose Chigo Mendez and mother, Herbert Simmons, Walt Butler, Alden Denila
On December 11th, 2009, we awarded four Students of the Month at Loma Alta Elementary. Principal Eric Sahakian selected Desiree Regalado, Leeona Jones, Antonio Taylor, and Ramon Banuelos as Loma Alta’s Students of the Month.
Desiree, Leeona, Antonio, and Ramon received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Loma Alta’s Teacher of the Month was Christine McQuinn, who received a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Desiree Regalado, Leeona Jones, Antonio Taylor, Christine McQuinn, Walt Butler, Herbert Simmons, Principal Eric Sahakian, Ramon Banuelos and sister (clockwise l-r)
On December 4th, 2009, we awarded three Students of the Month at Jackson Elementary. Principal Rose Ingber selected Ajarion Bailey (K) for his greatly improved attendance and strong academic achievement, Omar Reyes (4th) for being an outstanding and responsible student with great leadership skills, and Gustavo Alonso (4th) for also being an outstanding and responsible student with great leadership skills.
Ajaron, Omar, and Gustavo received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Jackson Elementary’s Teacher of the Month was Mrs. Ann Anderson, whom Principal Ingber selected for going above and beyond her call of duty. In addition to Mrs. Anderson’s strong teaching abilities, she has taken on many extra responsibilities at Jackson, such as School Site council, PTA, Student Government and site GATE coordinator.
Mrs. Anderson was awarded with a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Principal Rose Ingber, Gustavo Alonso, Ajarion Bailey, Ann Anderson, and Omar Reyes (l-r)
At Altadena Elementary the same day, we awarded three Students of the Month, who were Estela Zarate, Kenneth LaBomme, and Benjamin Baron. Each received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Kenneth LaBomme, Principal Gregory White, Estela Zarate, Herbert Simmons, and Benjamin Baron
Principal Gregory White selected Ms. Barela as Altadena’s Teacher of the Month, who received a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Principal White, Ms. Barela, Herbert Simmons
On December 2nd, 2009, we awarded three Students of the Month from Daniel Webster Elementary. Principal Sharon Lefler selected Eli Cid for trying his hardest every day and being friendly, outgoing, sweet, and kind. Bryan Strehl was selected for being a hard worker with a strong sense of right and wrong who gets along well with everyone. Tanine Griffin was also selected for being exceptionally friendly, kind, compassionate, and helpful.
Eli, Bryan, and Tanine received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Daniel Webster’s Teacher of the Month was Harriet Watts, who Principal Lefler praised for taking on extra responsibilities such as orchestrating monthly awards, being a PTA Board member, a liaison between the PTA Board and the staff, participating in the Good News Club, and much more. For the past couple of years, she has welcomed Special Education Inclusion students into her class, and she is bilingual in Spanish. Mrs. Watts has open communication with students, staff, and parents on an ongoing basis. Principal Lefler also commended Mrs. Watts’s sense of humor and positive attitude.
Mrs. Watts was awarded with a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a gift certificate to the Coffee Gallery, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Harriet Watts, Tanine Griffin, Principal Sharon Lefler, Bryan Strehl, and Eli Cid (l-r)
We also gave special recognition to Principal Sharon Lefler for being a wonderful supporter of the Student and Teacher of the Month Programs. Lefler’s prompt and thorough communications, as well as her dedication to her staff and students make her a pleasure to work with. Thank you, Mrs. Lefler, for your tireless commitment to education!
Principal Sharon Lefler and Herbert Simmons
On November 30th, 2009, we awarded the Student and Teacher of the Month at Burbank Elementary as well as Students of the Month at Eliot Middle School. At Burbank Elementary, Principal Kelly Lawson selected Andy Arevalo as the Student of the Month for his honest act of returning $400 that was found on the school bus. Though he was not present to receive his award, he was given a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, 2 free passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Burbank Elementary’s Teacher of the Month was Sharon Lundgren, who Dr. Lawson commended for her hard work.
Principal Kelly Lawson, Sharon Lundgren, Herbert Simmons, and Okorie Ezieme (l-r)
Later that day, we awarded the Students of the Month at Eliot Middle School. Karma Carter of the 7th grade and Aumari Sheldon of the 8th grade both received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Assistant Principal Lisa Branham, Karma Carter, and Herbert Simmons
Assistant Principal Lisa Branham, Aumari Sheldon, and Herbert Simmons
On November 13th, 2009, we awarded the Student and Teacher of the Month at Loma Alta Elementary and Franklin Elementary School. At Loma Alta, Principal Eric Sahakian selected 5th grader Karina Moya as the Student of the Month for being a responsible, cooperative student and outstanding role model who takes the initiative to do her work.
Karina received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a family 4 pack of passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Student of the Month Karina Moya, and Principal Eric Sahakian
Principal Sahakian selected Lila Schob as Loma Alta’s Teacher of the Month, describing her as “a caring individual who is involved with students and families of Loma Alta. She is never deterred by problems, instead rising to the occasion and working with others to reach a solution. She is a pleasure to collaborate with and makes Loma Alta a nurturing environment.”
Ms. Schob was awarded with a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a free movie pass to Laemmle Theatres, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Teacher of the Month Lila Schob, and Principal Eric Sahakian
We also visited Franklin Elementary, where Principal Caroline Bermudez selected 1st grader Amarie Strong as Franklin’s Student of the Month. Amarie’s teacher, Ms. Sarinas, commended Amarie for completing her homework every single day this year on her own and for being a wonderful student.
Amarie received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a family 4 pack of passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Alden Denila, Herbert Simmons, Student of the Month Amarie Strong and family, Principal Bermudez, and Ms. Sarinas
Franklin’s Teacher of the Month was Ms. Garza, who received a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a free movie pass to Laemmle Theatres, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons and son, Teacher of the Month Ms. Garza, Principal Bermudez, and Alden Denila
On November 6th, 2009, we visited Jackson Elementary to present their Student and Teacher of the Month for November. Principal Rose Ingber selected Stephanie Herrera (3rd grade) as Jackson’s Student of the Month, stating that Stephanie is a successful student who always does her best as is engaged in her learning. Principal Ingber added that Stephanie is considerate, friendly, helpful, and goes out of her way to assist others.
Stephanie was awarded with a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a family 4 pack of passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Student of the Month Stephanie Herrera, and Principal Rose Ingber
Jackson’s Teacher of the Month was Jacquelyn Wilson, who Principal Ingber recognized as an outstanding teacher who uses games and strategies to engage all her students in learning. In addition, for the past three years, she has volunteered to be an active participant in Jackson’s PTA and to be responsible for the membership drive. She is respected by her colleagues, students and parents.
Mrs. Wilson was awarded with a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a one month free membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a free movie pass to Laemmle Theatres, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Teacher of the Month Jacquelyn Wilson, and Principal Rose Ingber
Later that day, we awarded the Students and Teachers of the Month at Altadena Elementary. The Student of the Month was Yvette Gonzalez, who received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a family 4 pack of passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free movie pass to Pacific Paseo, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Principal Gregory White, Shelene Hearring of Two Dragons Martial Arts, and Student of the Month Yvette Gonzalez (clockwise l-r)
Altadena’s Teacher of the Month was Kelly Atkatz, selected by Principal Gregory White for “going over and beyond to make sure students and staff have everything they need to succeed.”
Herbert Simmons, Teacher of the Month Kelly Atkatz, and Principal Gregory White
On October 29th, 2009, we selected a Student and Teacher of the Month from Daniel Webster Elementary. Principal Sharon Lefler selected 3rd grader Bess Brandow as Webster’s Student of the Month and Ms. Ali Schulte as the Teacher of the Month.
Bess received a certificate provided by FedEx Office, a reusable bag from Whole Foods Market Arroyo, a family 4 pack of passes to Kidspace Museum, a free meal ticket at Islands and Souplantation, a free martial arts lesson from Two Dragons Martial Arts , a free visit to Under the Sea Indoor Playground, a free art lesson from KidsArt, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, a free tap lesson from Sue B. Dance Company, a bumper sticker, and a T-shirt.
Ms. Schulte received with a certificate provided by FedEx Office as well as decorative paper, a $25 gift certificate to Merit Cleaners, a free one-month membership from Curves Altadena, a $15 gift certificate to Big Mama’s Rib Shack, a $10 gift certificate to Brio Spas, a free movie pass to Laemmle Theatres, a free bowling game and shoe rental at 300 Pasadena, a free item ticket from McDonald’s, and a T-shirt.
Herbert Simmons, Student of the Month Bess Brandow, and Principal Sharon Lefler
Herbert Simmons, Teacher of the Month Ali Schulte, and Principal Lefler
Congratulations to all Students and Teachers of the Month!
#1 by Roland Yell on November 8th, 2009
Quote
I support Herbert Simmons in every thing he has done!
#2 by Clark Hansen on November 8th, 2009
Quote
Herbert Simmons is the only Altadena Town Council member who has ever attempted to reach out to constituents in our council district/census tract (whatever it’s called) in the 17 plus years that I’ve lived here. I don’t understand why the Town Council wants to remove an elected official who has made harmless mistakes, apologized for them, and has refrained from repeating them. Back in 1973, Kissinger and Nixon removed Salvador Allende who had been overwhelmingly elected by the people of Chile. His crime: wanting to do something meaningful for those who elected him. Is the Altadena Town Council a Pinochet dictatorship in miniature? Why the secrecy? Will people begin “disappearing” from Altadena next?
#3 by Jaime Johnson on November 8th, 2009
Quote
Herbert Simmons is a positive role model in the Altadena community, I don’t understand why the Town Council want to remove him from office. It is people like Mr. Simmons that gives our children hope for the future. The student/teacher of the month program is a magnificant program that provides incentives for both students and teachers to be shining lights unto the rest of the world. REMOVING MR. SIMMONS FROM OFFICE WILL BE A GREAT MISFORTUNE FOR THE TOWN COUNCIL….THEY ARE MAKING A BIG MISTAKE… HERBERT SIMMONS IS A BRILLANT MAN…
#4 by Altadena on November 9th, 2009
Quote
The Altadena Town Council is controlled by a few members and their business buddies whose goal is to enrich themselves and their egos. The rest of of the council members are a bunch of “yes” men and women with no backbone. Mr. Simmons is rocking the boat by refusing to submit to this “leadership.” This is a threat to the “old guard” of the council and explains their efforts to remove Mr. Simmons.
#5 by Ethan F. Allen on November 10th, 2009
Quote
The Altadena Town Council clearly has misunderstood the spirit of Mr. Simmons’ actions and are, in my opinion, acting a bit heavy handed by passing a summary judgment to remove him from office .
Mr. Simmons did what many inexperienced politicians do. He made mistakes. He assumed that a great idea, if executed autonomously and with minimal impact on council resources, would be accepted on its own merits. I can’t imagine how many blockbuster ideas die on the house floor in Congress or how many industry killer patents some scientist came up with that simply cannot be acted upon for the greater good. This is politics. Perhaps Mr. Simmons assumed his resourcefulness, creativity and high energy would be accepted by the council and that it (The Council) would weigh in on and offer unbiased commentary and discussion on programs he presented and after debate, decided on.
If Mr. Simmons had had a friend on the council, he might have had a mentor giving guidance and council on how to properly proceed with presenting a program the acceptable way. As it seems, instead of having co-council members to work with, Mr. Simmons in stead had a review committee who simply sat back, watched him make mistakes, evaluated performance, made judgments, declared themselves right and him wrong and eventually cut Mr. Simmons off at the knees simply because they could.
I know Herb Simmons to be a reasonable man. It seems to me that if the council wanted to work with Mr. Simmons at all, they would not have made this kind of decision so quickly. I would strongly urge the council and Mr. Simmons to drop your guards, stop the accusations, be fearless, engage in candor and achieve real communications. This does not have to happen.
My $.02
#6 by Ninarose Mayer on November 12th, 2009
Quote
What I don’t understand is how the Altadena Town Council has the authority (if it exists) to eject from the council a member elected by his constituents in a legal election. This is an unheard of matter in all the almost 50 yrs. of my living here. I say SHAME on the Town Council for its actions in this matter.
Ninarose Mayer
#7 by Roland Yell on November 13th, 2009
Quote
I stand behind herbert Simmons in every thing He has done.
#8 by Roosevelt Pullem on November 13th, 2009
Quote
I speak as we the people voted Mr Simmons into the ATC position, Now Iunderstand other ATC members want to kick him out, for what appears to be a behavior matter! Resulting in a personality conflict?
There must be other ways of resolving this matter?
How about taking it to ARBITRATION To resolve.
#9 by John Torres on November 13th, 2009
Quote
Herbert Simmons is a positive, recognizable presence in Altadena. He is a man who cares deeply about this community. He has made it his priority to raise awareness and bring deserved recognition to the formerly unsung educators in our community. He has worked tirelessly to bring long-needed adequate cell phone reception to our area. His efforts to unify and inform the community during the Station Fire are testament alone to this man’s dedication to Altadena.
I lived in this community for 5 yrs before I even knew the ATC existed! I still wouldn’t had Herbert Simmons not knocked on my door one day and introduced himself. I never could have imagined that such an ineffably, inexhaustibly, civic-minded individual resided here. Herbert Simmons makes me proud to live Altadena!
#10 by Virgie Collier on November 13th, 2009
Quote
So do we want Politicians and Councilmen who cover up the truth, or ones who exposes the truth? I for one would want to have someone like Councilman Herbert Simmons who stands for the truth and exposes what is wrong and instead of covering up what is wrong.
Town council if you are pointing one finger how many are pointing back at you?
#11 by Peggy HIll on November 13th, 2009
Quote
It’s obvious that Mr. Simmons started a money collecting fund without first reaching out to the council. Do any of the residents and business know how much money was sent to Mr. Simmons? No because there’s no balance or check. That was what I felt was not a good look. There has to be some type of structure before I start contributing money to such a worthy cause. I have pointed this out to Mr. Simmons several times, when he firsrt emailed me his idea.
#12 by admin on November 13th, 2009
Quote
I do not understand your comment. You have to collect money in order to start a money collecting fund. Every penny I received was returned back to the supporters. All donations from businesses were in the form of coupons and certificates, in an effort to promote their businesses. It has also been stated several times that the student and teacher of the month programs, this website, the informal town hall dinner (catering and room rental) , the Altadena community newsletter and over 300 T-shirts given to the community,students and teachers have all been funded by myself only. I do not charge local businesses fees to advertise on this site. I have set this site up as a service to communicate with the community. I have not accepted money from anyone. Even the Altadena Town Council knows that I did not accept any money, or else they would have certainly listed it under their allegations against me. Thank you for your comment.
#13 by David Sandstrom on November 14th, 2009
Quote
Mr Simmons is the only representative that goes out to the community. He knows who he represents because he knocked on our doors. He goes to the schools and shows achievement. He informs us. I’ve lived in Altadena for 12 years and have felt no representation until Mr. Simmons arrived. We don’t live in a secret society. I vote everyone who attends a secret meeting be terminated. What was said? Where is the defense. This is not how it should be. Mr Simmons apologized and made corrections. Can the council secret members do the same?
#14 by Chuck Malouf, Retired Muir Teacher on November 14th, 2009
Quote
What is going on? You have a new member in Herbie Simmons and he is trying his best to do what is best for Altadena. He started the Teacher and Student of the Month program and he is visible in the community. If a few minor infractions have occurred, he is still learning. Have any of the ATC members ever made minor mistakes? Does absolute power by some corrupt absolutely? If they all worked together and shared their ideas, they would all be successful and have power? It takes a team to win a championship and they do this while working together. What is happening to team unity? Consider seriously about what you might decide on Nov. 17!!
Chuck Malouf
#15 by Dr. Eric MacCalla, P.E. on November 14th, 2009
Quote
TO Altadena Town Council
RE: OBJECTION TO REMOVAL OF HERBERT SIMMONS AT ATC COUNCILMAN
I am a former ATC Councilman for 4603 (~1980-1985), current Block Captain for the Chaney Trail Area, and serve on the Sheriff’s Community Advisory Council. I am speaking as an individual and my views do not represent those of organizations I belong to. I list my activity to say that I have been actively involved and concerned with the welfare of Altadena and I think Councilman Herbert Simmons has shown similar concern.
It has come to my attention that a committee has convened and voted in majority to remove Herbert Simmons as Councilman. I strongly object to such a move. I have followed his activities since he was elected and he has shown enthusiasm and concern for the betterment of Altadena. Some actions may appear to be very assertive but fall within good intentions. I have personally criticized him for some of his assertive actions and he has considered my concerns.
I have served as an officer on the ATC, Altadena Recreation Council, and Westside Residents Association, and have been actively involved in lots of community issues. I know how important it is to get people involved to help share the workload, even if you do not agree with them. Altadena has lots of active citizens and it is good to have channeled energy. Your actions discourage and even punish such activity and this does not help establish the credibility of the Altadena Town Council. I find it unusual that Council members can remove an elected representative. I’ve heard of censorship and reprimands by fellow representatives in such places as Congress, the Senate, and in local elected bodies but I am not aware of elected officials removing fellow elected officials. That should be limited to constituents of the electing body or by statute in case of felony convictions.
Please reconsider your recommendation to remove Herbert Simmons. Any actions to address removal at a minimum should be in open session where Altadena citizens can witness an open and fair process with community input.
Dr. Eric MacCalla, P.E.
Former representative-4603 and ATC officer
#16 by EVANGELIST DARRELL BURCH on November 15th, 2009
Quote
I voted for Councilman Herbert Simmons. The job he has done I think has gone far and above of what is required of a councilman. The actions that are being taken against him I think are unfair and unjust. His work in the school system is better than any other person on the board has done or could do.
#17 by Roosevelt Pullem on November 15th, 2009
Quote
I am in agreement with the comment or motion if you will of the above comment Dr. Eric MacCalla, P.E.
I second it.
Roosevelt
#18 by Peggy HIll on November 16th, 2009
Quote
Mr. Simmons, You need email me for contributions for Teacher/Student of the month. I still have that email, which says nothing about you coming out of your pockets, rather money coming out of the pockets of the residents.
I work in the corporate world, so I guess you don’t quite understand about structure.
#19 by admin on November 16th, 2009
Quote
I initially gave residents an opportunity to get involved in the programs. However, I did not end up accepting any funds from anyone. I suggest at this moment that we set up a face to face meeting due to the fact that emails can often be confusing and misunderstood. Please let me know your availability.
#20 by Rose Marie McZeal on November 16th, 2009
Quote
I believe the council is very wrong to remove an elected official. What message are you sending to the voters? Or is your message Census Tract 4602 doesn’t count??
#21 by Valley Phoenix on November 19th, 2009
Quote
When have we noticed any young men trying to make a difference in the community; here we have young man, who has volunteered his time, his family, his personal income, and efforts; and the town council who is OLD and OUT DATED is taking offense to him; why, is it because they are not doing sh>>>t. They are too old, and now they are embarrassed. Well you should be embarrassed and get OUT of HERBERT’s way; Are you AltaDena Town Council going to honor the students and businesses; NO you are going to sit on your fat –ss, drink coffee and do nothing; so get out of way and leave this young man BE!
SS
#22 by Virgie Collier on November 23rd, 2009
Quote
Please reconsider your action on the remval of Herbert Simmons. We need a fresh young mind from someone who is dedicated not ony to Family and Friends but to his Community. What changes has the Town Council done? From what I have seen and know nothing since Herbert Simmons election change good and growth in the community Unity. I am proud of his Acomplishments. Thank yOU
#23 by Desi Larkin on November 24th, 2009
Quote
I voted for Councilman Herbert Simmons in a legal election. What you people are doing is obscene. Councilman Simmons has been the only elected official that has been communicating with the community. Stop the madness.
#24 by Rayne Stewart, Retired Educator on November 25th, 2009
Quote
Name: Rayne Stewart I am a Retired Teacher for the Pasadena Unified School District. I have just received an Altadena Community Alert flyer. To my dismay, I find that the Council has decided to remove Herbert Simmons. He has done an excellent job in providing recognition for the teachers of our Community who need the extra boost and support from the community. What investigation? Why can’t you as a council come to some sort of aggreement and meet together to reconcile your differences. I think this is slanderous that the community has to hear about this. Can’t you meet to agree to disagree before something like this reaches our community. Note: I don’t appreciate receiving flyers at my doorstep from a council who is suppose to represent all of us without a united front.
#25 by admin on November 25th, 2009
Quote
Thank you for taking your time to make your comment and opinion known to the community. The flyer was placed on your doorstep by my supporters to alert the community of the lack of due process in regards to the Town Council’s attempt to remove me from my elected position over the votes of the people. We only have two ways of reaching the community: one is by e-mail and the other is by flyer or newsletter for those who may not be on our e-mail list. I apologize if it has been a bother, but please understand and share this information with all of your neighbors.
#26 by Michael Rost on November 29th, 2009
Quote
I echo the comments and concerns above. I may not agree with all of Mr. Simmons politics, policies, or views. However, if I don’t like them I can vote someone else in next time. At least he is engaged and doing something productive. This removal effort seems to be the equivalent of a lynching or witch hunt. It’s embarrassing for Altadena.
#27 by Kalena Broom on November 30th, 2009
Quote
It is unfortunate that the non participators want to rid the participators to validate their own stagnation. This young man is making a difference and engaging the community in a positive way. And instead of embracing his action and mentoring his path, you choose to attempt to remove him from the Council. (And In closed session) You are aware that, that is done in the dark will come to the Light. You should be ashamed to let your community know your best intensions are not for Altadena but for yourselves.
#28 by gloriana casey on December 4th, 2009
Quote
Well, here it is December, and the council member who really is bringing “joy to the World” through his work for students and teachers of Altadena, is Herbert Simmons! The citizens of 4602 are singing out in appreciation of work needed and work done! Are the other council members tone deaf?
#29 by Kate on December 4th, 2009
Quote
You need to go over to altadenablog, he just put up a post that is very negative towards Herbert Simmons. What can those of us in 4602 do about this whole controversy? I do not understand why this misunderstanding cannot be resolved, and I also do not understand people’s opposition to the concept of Simmons’ program (see comment on altadenablog.) I understand opposition to the initial misrepresentation of the program, but now it seems that some people are attacking Simmons for the actual program itself.
#30 by admin on December 4th, 2009
Quote
Thank you for your comments and concern. Please join the write-in campaign and share this information with each of your neighbors. Encourage them to join the write-in campaign as well, and address your letters to Chairman Sund, and most importantly, cc: the Pasadena Weekly and Star-News. We must inform as many in the community as possible to give them a choice. (See “Write-In Campaign” under the Current Issues tab) Next, and most importantly, please attend the next Altadena Town Council Meeting on December 15th and demand a positive end to this unnecessary controversy.
#31 by Ryen Dorg on December 4th, 2009
Quote
The ATC has always had an inflated sense of self-importance. Through its quasi-legislative actions and the manner in which its members are elected — even the nomenclature of its bylaws — it holds itself out to be a “representative body” for Altadena, with the supervisor being Altadena’s “executive.” But when matters are tough, its members will conveniently cloak themselves under the thin shield of being merely an advisory board, to which rules of open government and transparency do not apply.
In 2001, census tract 4610 residents had to get then- council member C. R. Tillman removed through the recall process because the council wouldn’t oust him, despite his obvious, well-documented misconduct. ATC members position then was that it would be up to residents of his tract to remove him. So they drafted the petition, got the required signatures, and got over 600% of the required voters to remove him. It would have been more appropriate for the ATC to remove him than have residents recall him. But that is now the precedence.
So my position is the ATC has no foundation for removing Mr. Simmons. His misconduct comes no where near that of Tillman’s. And Mr. Simmons has taken steps to ensure that his programs represent those in his capacity as a member of the ATC from his tract, and not the ATC itself. Thus, under existing precedence, only his tract residents can remove him if, in their judgment, he has acted improperly.
In my humble opinion.
#32 by Homer and Earline Bell on December 11th, 2009
Quote
Let me get this straight…..he’s being accused of embezzlement or misappropriation of funds or overstepping the council’s bounds? What is it, if it’s a matter of protocol then removal is overkill. Give the young man an opportunity to learn and help the community he’s grown up in develop a rising star. He was voted in by the community and he is to be removed then let the community vote on his removal.
#33 by sandy ampon on December 14th, 2009
Quote
What a shame! And we thought it only happened in Washington. Ha Ha Ha right here in our own backyard!
Isn’t time that we become the change that we demand of one another so very often. It’s time for the old guard to share some of the space with the future,
While it’s true, Mr. Simmons might be a bit different-or awkward -a few shortcomings, his desire to support the community is undeniable. His heart us truly suncered One needs only to look at the letters from the students and teachers to realize the positive impact his so called negative work as done for them,
I think, that if he can inspire our children and acknowledge teachers by designing and paying for a simple t-shirt we ought to be proud. Besides, it’s a small price to pay to encourage a child to stay in school.
It’ definitely better than any rap record, movie or poster I’ve seen or heard lately. And, doggone better than the sounds of gunshots going off in the air or murdering our children!
A dear friend once told me “When you point a finger at someone, remember there are 4 more pointing back at you!” I think all 10 need to be focused on nurturing and
protecting our future and anyine that stands up to do so.
Herbie he needs to be groomed and nurtured as well.
#34 by Suzanne Firlotte on December 14th, 2009
Quote
Dear Herbert,
THANK YOU for stepping up and helping. It is very admirable. Sorry you are dealing with a group that has their own agenda.
Apparently the town council hasn’t noticed the shape the school’s are in around here. Shame on them for not following your footsteps by rolling up their sleeves and doing something to fix it.
I think your ideas to reward those doing well are correct, and puts emphasis on the good instead of the bad.
Thank you again for setting a good example by being willing to get involved.
#35 by Peggy HIll on December 15th, 2009
Quote
Mr. Simmons,
What are the Town Council allegations against you? And why should the Town Council be under the Brown Act, if the Council is not a government body?
Is there a criminal check on Altadena Town Council members? Do you think there should be?
You were a very active Council member, good luck in your future endeavors.
#36 by admin on December 15th, 2009
Quote
Hi Ms. Hill. The allegations are listed under the “Current Issues” tab. To answer your questions, the Town Council should follow the Brown Act if it wishes to legitimize itself as a group that represents itself as the governing body of Altadena. In a similar case in Agua Dulce, another unincorporated area of Los Angeles, a court ruling determined that the Agua Dulce Town Council was subject to the Brown Act despite its lack of legislative authority.
To my knowledge, criminal background checks on ATC Members are not conducted, though the bylaws state that a felony conviction is grounds for removal.
I believe many things need to be revamped with the Altadena Town Council, the first being legitimizing itself and respecting the vote of the people, or you might as well not have elections.
#37 by IRA Rules on January 10th, 2010
Quote
Thank you so much, there aren’t enough posts on this… or at least i cant find them. I am turning into such a blog nut, I just cant get enough and this is such an important topic… i’ll be sure to write something about your site
#38 by IRA Rules on January 12th, 2010
Quote
Great post! keep them comin… thanks for all your hard work.